Eugene Mayevski 'EldoS Eugene Mayevski 'EldoS - 8 months ago 72
Android Question

onActivityResult() called prematurely

I start the activity (descendant of PreferenceActivity) from my worker activity as follows:

protected void onActivityResult(int requestCode, int resultCode, Intent data)
super.onActivityResult(requestCode, resultCode, data);
if (requestCode == 1458)

void showSettingsDialog()
startActivityForResult(new Intent().setClass(this, MyConfigure.class), 1458);

MyConfigure class does NOT have any setResult() calls. In fact, MyConfigure class doesn't have any code except OnCreate where it loads preferences using addPreferencesFromResource.

Now onActivityResult is called with requestCode of 1458 prematurely, right after MyConfigure activity is run. Tested on 1.6 and 2.1 emulators as well as 2.1 device. Is there a call to setResult() buried somewhere in PreferenceActivity? Or how else can this premature call be explained?

Answer Source

There's a bug / feature (?) in Android, which immediately reports result (which has not been set yet) for activity, declared as singleTask (despite the fact that the activity continues to run). If we change launchMode of the parent activity from singleTask to singleTop, everything works as expected - result is reported only after the activity is finished. While this behavior has certain explanation (only one singleTask activity can exist and there can happen multiple waiters for it), this is still a not logical restriction for me.