noitseuq noitseuq - 11 months ago 53
jQuery Question

jQuery $el.trigger('change') doesn't fire native listeners

Consider the following HTML:

<select value="val2">
<option value="val1">o1</option>
<option value="val2">o2</option>

And JavaScript (performed on document ready):

var $select = $('select');
var select = $select.get(0);

function logger(msg) {
return function () { console.log(msg); };

$select.on('change', logger('jquery on select'));
$(document).on('change', logger('jquery on document'));

select.addEventListener('change', logger('native on select'), false);
document.addEventListener('change', logger('native on document'), false);

setTimeout(function () {
console.log(' == programmatic ==');
console.log(' == now try manual ==');
}, 1000);

This results to the following output in the console:

== programmatic ==
jquery on select
jquery on document
== now try manual ==
jquery on select
native on select
jquery on document
native on document

The question is: why are natively bound listeners not called? How make them be called?

Here's also a jsFiddle:

(Using jQuery 2.0.2)


This article gives a good overview of the topic:

Triggering Event Handlers

Basically, trigger will only fire event handlers attached through jQuery or certain event handler attributes in the html.

You can define a plugin to trigger a native browser event like this:

(function($) {

    $.fn.trigger2 = function(eventName) {
        return this.each(function() {
            var el = $(this).get(0);
            triggerNativeEvent(el, eventName);

    function triggerNativeEvent(el, eventName){
      if (el.fireEvent) { // < IE9
        (el.fireEvent('on' + eventName));
      } else {
        var evt = document.createEvent('Events');
        evt.initEvent(eventName, true, false);


// sample usage

This is not perfect but should give you the general idea.

Here's an update to your fiddle using this plugin.