solar apricot solar apricot - 25 days ago 7
Java Question

why not call service class directly from jsp

So i have a sort of design question:
I have a jsp, and a controller that fetched the data for that jsp. Some of that data come from service classes.
I know that mvc pattern tells me to use the controller to call the service class and pass that info to my view (jsp).
Why can't I call the service class from my jsp directly?

Answer

You can, and that's what developers sometimes do. But you shouldn't.

MVC is about interchangeability and separation of concerns. If you call your service from JSP, you create a tight coupling, to parameters and return types, for example.

Moreover, usually, systems are not developed singlehandedly. Let's say you have getAllAdmins() method in your service, which you use for internal logic. Do you really want another developer to use it directly in JSP, and by mistake display all your admins? Probably not.

Comments