mmollle mmollle - 1 year ago 71
C Question

C program is behaving giving weird values in Windows but works fine in Ubuntu

I wrote a program for a small task in school on my laptop with Ubuntu on. I wasnt having any problems when writing the program. It worked perfectly fine and did everything it should. But when I moved it over to my Windows PC it gave me some very weird values and I cant seem to figure out whats wrong with it. I use the same IDE, CodeBlocks 16.01, on both Ubuntu and Windows. Ive been trying to solve this for several hours but im stuck so I would really appreciate some help.

If I for example enter the value 50 on every prompt I will get the results of 200 in both printf-methods after the while-loop, like it should be since 50+50+50+50 equals 200. In windows however I get 240 in total_weight and 100 in total_height which to me doesnt make any sense. Whats the cause of this?

#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>

int main()
int weights[3], heights[3], i = 0;
int total_weight, total_height;

while (i <= 3)
printf("Person %d, enter your weight (kg): ",i+1);
printf("Person %d, enter your height (cm): ",i+1);
scanf("%d", &heights[i]);

//Calculations for total weight and total length of all the people
total_weight = total_weight + weights[i];
total_height = total_height + heights[i];

printf("\n\tPerson %d's weight and height: %dkg, %dcm\n\n", i+1, weights[i], heights[i]);

//Printing the results of the earlier calculations
printf("\tTotal weight of everyone: %d\n", total_weight);
printf("\tTotal height of everyone: %d\n", total_height);

return 0;


Answer Source

In your code, by saying

 while (i <= 3)

you're going off-by-one. This invokes undefined behavior, for out-of-bound memory access.

To elaborate, C arrays have 0-based indexing. So for an array with a dimension of 3, will have valid indexes from 0 to 2, inclusive.

So, you should use

while (i < 3)

to stay in the bounds.

That said, in your code, total_weight and total_height are automatic local variables and they are used uninitialized. Hence, they contain indeterminstic values and using them causes UB, again. You have to explicitly initialize them to, say, 0.

Recommended from our users: Dynamic Network Monitoring from WhatsUp Gold from IPSwitch. Free Download