user3654258 user3654258 - 2 months ago 30
Swift Question

Swift 3 - Structs in a Collection

Why doesn't the following code work? And what do I need to change to make it work?

//: Playground - noun: a place where people can play

import Cocoa

struct Person: CustomDebugStringConvertible, Hashable {
let name: String
let age: Int

// MARK: CustomDebugStringConvertible

var debugDescription: String {
return "\(name) is \(age) years old"

// MARK: Hashable

var hashValue: Int {
return name.hashValue ^ age.hashValue

func ==(lhs: Person, rhs: Person) -> Bool {
return == && lhs.age == rhs.age

let ilse = Person(name: "Ilse", age: 33)
let mark = Person(name: "Mark", age: 38)

extension Collection where Iterator.Element: Person {
var averageAge: Int {
let sum = self.reduce(0) { $0 + $1.age }
let count = self.count as! Int
return sum / count

var people = [Person]()

let averageAge = people.averageAge

I figured out that if I make the struct a Swift class it works. Does it have something to do with the struct being a value type? I do see a compiler error on the last line. "'[Person]' is not convertible to '<>'"

Thank you.

extension Collection where Iterator.Element: Person

restricts Iterator.Element to types which adopt the protocol Person or are a subclass of Person. Both is not possible with struct Person, and in the full compiler log you'll find

error: type 'Iterator.Element' constrained to non-protocol type 'Person'

What you probably mean is

extension Collection where Iterator.Element == Person 

which restricts the extension to collections of Person. Alternatively, define a protocol

protocol HasAge {
    var age: Int { get }

adopt that by Person

struct Person: CustomDebugStringConvertible, Hashable, HasAge { ... }

and define the extension for collections of elements which have a age:

extension Collection where Iterator.Element: HasAge { ... }