deamon deamon - 3 months ago 10
Python Question

Python: Should I use a class or dictionary?

I have a class that contains only fields and no methods, like this:

class Request(object):

def __init__(self, environ):
self.environ = environ
self.request_method = environ.get('REQUEST_METHOD', None)
self.url_scheme = environ.get('wsgi.url_scheme', None)
self.request_uri = wsgiref.util.request_uri(environ)
self.path = environ.get('PATH_INFO', None)
# ...


This could easily be translated to a dict. The class is more flexible for future additions and could be fast with
__slots__
. So would there be a benefit of using a dict instead? Would a dict be faster than a class? And faster than a class with slots?

adw adw
Answer

Why on earth would you make this a dictionary? What's the advantage? What happens if you later want to add some code? Where would your __init__ code go?

Classes are for bundling related data (and usually code).

Dictionaries are for storing key-value relationships, where usually the keys are all of the same type, and all the values are also of one type. Occasionally they can be useful for bundling data when the key/attribute names are not all known up front, but often this a sign that something's wrong with your design.

Keep this a class.

Comments