Kirill V. Lyadvinsky Kirill V. Lyadvinsky - 1 year ago 142
C++ Question

Purpose of Trigraph sequences in C++?

According to C++'03 Standard 2.3/1:

Before any other processing takes place, each occurrence of one of the following sequences of three characters (“trigraph sequences”) is replaced by the single character indicated in Table 1.

| trigraph | replacement | trigraph | replacement | trigraph | replacement |
| ??= | # | ??( | [ | ??< | { |
| ??/ | \ | ??) | ] | ??> | } |
| ??’ | ˆ | ??! | | | ??- | ˜ |

In real life that means that code
printf( "What??!\n" );
will result in printing
is a trigraph sequence that is replaced with the

My question is what purpose of using trigraphs? Is there any practical advantage of using trigraphs?

UPD: In answers was mentioned that some European keyboards don't have all the punctuation characters, so non-US programmers have to use trigraphs in everyday life?

UPD2: Visual Studio 2010 has trigraph support turned off by default.

Answer Source

This question (about the closely related digraphs) has the answer.

It boils down to the fact that the ISO 646 character set doesn't have all the characters of the C syntax, so there are some systems with keyboards and displays that can't deal with the characters (though I imagine that these are quite rare nowadays).

In general, you don't need to use them, but you need to know about them for exactly the problem you ran into. Trigraphs are the reason the the '?' character has an escape sequence:


So a couple ways you can avoid your example problem are:

 printf( "What?\?!\n" ); 

 printf( "What?" "?!\n" );

But you have to remember when you're typing the two '?' characters that you might be starting a trigraph (and it's certainly never something I'm thinking about).

In practice, trigraphs and digraphs are something I don't worry about at all on a day-to-day basis. But you should be aware of them because once every couple years you'll run into a bug related to them (and you'll spend the rest of the day cursing their existance). It would be nice if compilers could be configured to warn (or error) when it comes across a trigraph or digraph, so I could know I've got something I should knowingly deal with.

And just for completeness, digraphs are much less dangerous since they get processed as tokens, so a digraph inside a string literal won't get interpreted as a digraph.

For a nice education on various fun with punctuation in C/C++ programs (including a trigraph bug that would defintinely have me pulling my hair out), take a look at Herb Sutter's GOTW #86 article.


It looks like GCC will not process (and will warn about) trigraphs by default. Some other compilers have options to turn off trigraph support (IBM's for example). Microsoft started supporting a warning (C4837) in VS2008 that must be explicitly enabled (using -Wall or something).

Recommended from our users: Dynamic Network Monitoring from WhatsUp Gold from IPSwitch. Free Download