Ross Ross - 5 months ago 37
Java Question

Java equivalent of function mapping in Python

In python, if I have a few functions that I would like to call based on an input, i can do this:

lookup = {'function1':function1, 'function2':function2, 'function3':function3}

That is I have a dictionary of function name mapped to the function, and call the function by a dictionary lookup.

How to do this in java?


There are several ways to approach this problem. Most of these were posted already:

  • Commands - Keep a bunch of objects that have an execute() or invoke() method in a map; lookup the command by name, then invoke the method.
  • Polymorphism - More generally than commands, you can invoke methods on any related set of objects.
  • Finally there is Reflection - You can use reflection to get references to java.lang.Method objects. For a set of known classes/methods, this works fairly well and there isn't too much overhead once you load the Method objects. You could use this to, for example, allow a user to type java code into a command line, which you execute in real time.

Personally I would use the Command approach. Commands combine well with Template Methods, allowing you to enforce certain patterns on all your command objects. Example:

public abstract class Command {
  public final Object execute(Map<String, Object> args) {
    // do permission checking here or transaction management
    Object retval = doExecute(args);
    // do logging, cleanup, caching, etc here
    return retval;
  // subclasses override this to do the real work
  protected abstract Object doExecute(Map<String, Object> args);

I would resort to reflection only when you need to use this kind of mapping for classes whose design you don't control, and for which it's not practical to make commands. For example, you couldn't expose the Java API in a command-shell by making commands for each method.