Pacerier Pacerier - 3 months ago 15
Java Question

Is the left-to-right order of operations guaranteed in Java?

Consider this function:

public static final int F(int a, int b) {
a = a - 1 + b;
// and some stuff
return a;

Is it required for implementations of JVMs to execute
- 1
+ b

If we have a system profiler attached to the JVM, will we see the
+ b
operation being carried out before the
+ 1


Actually, I will disagree with the rest of the answers. The JLS §15.7 that people are referring to discusses the evaluation of operands. That is, in the expression

x = foo() - 1 + bar()

, in which order will the methods be invoked.

The relevant section is §15.7.3, which specifies

An implementation may not take advantage of algebraic identities such as the associative law to rewrite expressions into a more convenient computational order unless it can be proven that the replacement expression is equivalent in value and in its observable side effects [...]

Since the expression x = x - 1 + q is equivalent in all ways to x = x + q - 1, a conforming implementation is allowed to rewrite the expression (if it for some reason should decide that is more efficient).