Vitalii Korsakov Vitalii Korsakov - 3 months ago 22
Node.js Question

What's the difference between dependencies, devDependencies and peerDependencies in npm package.json file?

This documentation answers my question very poorly. I didn't understand those explanations. Can someone say in simpler words? Maybe with examples if it's hard to choose simple words?

EDIT also added

peerDependencies
, which is closely related and might cause confusion.

Answer

Summary of important behavior differences:

  • dependencies are installed on both:

    • npm install from a directory that contains package.json
    • npm install $package on any other directory
  • devDependencies are:

    • also installed on npm install on a directory that contains package.json, unless you pass the --production flag (go upvote Gayan Charith's answer).
    • not installed on npm install "$package" on any other directory, unless you give it the --dev option.
    • are not installed transitively.
  • peerDependencies:

    • before 3.0: are always installed if missing, and raise an error if multiple incompatible versions of the dependency would be used by different dependencies.
    • expected starting on 3.0 (untested): give a warning if missing on npm install, and you have to solve the dependency yourself manually. When running, if the dependency is missing, you get an error (mentioned by @nextgentech)
  • Transitivity (mentioned by Ben Hutchison):

    • dependencies are installed transitively: if A requires B, and B requires C, then C gets installed, otherwise B could not work, and neither would A.

    • devDependencies are not installed transitively. E.g. we don't need to test B to test A, so B's testing dependencies can be left out.

Related options not discussed here:

devDependencies

dependencies are required to run, devDependencies only to develop, e.g.: unit tests, Coffeescript to Javascript transpilation, minification, ...

If you are going to develop a package, you download it (e.g. via git clone), go to its root which contains package.json, and run:

npm install

Since you have the actual source, it is clear that you want to develop it, so by default both dependencies (since you must of course run to develop) and devDependency dependencies are also installed.

If however you are only an end user who just wants to install a package to use it, you will do from any directory:

npm install "$package"

In that case, you normally don't want the development dependencies, so you just get what is needed to use the package: dependencies.

If you really want to install development packages in that case, you can set the dev config option to true, possibly from the command line as:

npm install "$package" --dev

The option is false by default since this is a much less common case.

peerDependencies

(tested before 3.0)

Source: https://nodejs.org/en/blog/npm/peer-dependencies/ -http://blog.nodejs.org/2013/02/07/peer-dependencies/

With regular dependencies, you can have multiple versions of the dependency: it's simply installed inside the node_modules of the dependency.

E.g. if dependency1 and dependency2 both depend on dependency3 at different versions the project tree will look like:

root/node_modules/
                 |
                 +- dependency1/node_modules/
                 |                          |
                 |                          +- dependency3 v1.0/
                 |
                 |
                 +- dependency2/node_modules/
                                            |
                                            +- dependency3 v2.0/

Plugins however are packages that normally don't require the other package, which is called the host in this context. Instead:

  • plugins are required by the host
  • plugins offer a standard interface that the host expects to find
  • only the host will be called directly by the user, so there must be a single version of it.

E.g. if dependency1 and dependency2 peer depend on dependency3, the project tree will look like:

root/node_modules/
                 |
                 +- dependency1/
                 |
                 +- dependency2/
                 |
                 +- dependency3 v1.0/

This happens even though you never mention dependency3 in your package.json file.

I think this is an instance of the Inversion of Control design pattern.

A prototypical example of peer dependencies is Grunt, the host, and its plugins.

For example, on a Grunt plugin like https://github.com/gruntjs/grunt-contrib-uglify, you will see that:

  • grunt is a peerDependency
  • the only require('grunt') is under tests/: it's not actually used by the program.

Then, when the user will use a plugin, he will implicitly require the plugin from the Gruntfile by adding a grunt.loadNpmTasks('grunt-contrib-uglify') line, but it's grunt that the user will call directly.

This would not work then if each plugin required a different Grunt version.

Manual

I think the doc answers the question quite well, maybe you are not just familiar enough with node / other package managers. I probably only understand it because I know a bit about Ruby bundler.

The key line is:

These things will be installed when doing npm link or npm install from the root of a package, and can be managed like any other npm configuration param. See npm-config(7) for more on the topic.

And then under npm-config(7) find dev:

Default: false
Type: Boolean

Install dev-dependencies along with packages.