Mark Harrison Mark Harrison - 8 months ago 35
C++ Question

Is there a performance difference between i++ and ++i in C++?

We have the question is there a performance difference between

in C?

What's the answer for C++?


[Executive Summary: Use ++i if you don't have a specific reason to use i++.]

For C++, the answer is a bit more complicated.

If i is a simple type (not an instance of a C++ class), then the answer given for C ("No there is no performance difference") holds, since the compiler is generating the code.

However, if i is an instance of a C++ class, then i++ and ++i are making calls to one of the operator++ functions. Here's a standard pair of these functions:

Foo& Foo::operator++()   // called for ++i
    this->data += 1;
    return *this;

Foo Foo::operator++(int ignored_dummy_value)   // called for i++
    Foo tmp(*this);   // variable "tmp" cannot be optimized away by the compiler
    return tmp;

Since the compiler isn't generating code, but just calling an operator++ function, there is no way to optimize away the tmp variable and its associated copy constructor. If the copy constructor is expensive, then this can have a significant performance impact.

(Thanks to Paul for inquiring about the difference between C and C++.)