Nisd - 1 month ago 7

Javascript Question

Sorting decimal numbers using

`Intl.Collator`

`numeric`

On some browsers comparing "0.005" and "0.05" returns "0" as in the numbers are the same.

Results in different browsers:

- Chrome 54 = 0
- Firefox 49 = 0
- Edge = -1
- IE 11 = -1

`// Returns 0`

console.log(new Intl.Collator(undefined, { numeric: true}).compare(0.000005, 0.05))

Anyone that can tell me whats wrong?

Reported as bug in Firefox: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1312388

Answer

As André Bargull observes in the Firefox bug report, numeric sorting considers *only* decimal digit sequences, i.e. in the Unicode category of Number, by their numeric values. That is, when comparing two otherwise-identical strings containing decimal numbers with fractional components, the entire decimal numbers aren't considered for their numeric value -- because U+002E FULL STOP isn't in the Number category (it's instead in the Punctuation category).

So then, when we compare these two strings -- "0.05" and "0.000005" -- we effectively are comparing these arrays of elements:

```
["0", ".", "05"]
["0", ".", "000005"]
```

and then when digit sequences are considered by their numeric values, we're comparing

```
[0, ".", 5]
[0, ".", 5]
```

which are equal, and so `compare`

should return 0 when comparing them. Firefox and Chrome are right here, and IE and Edge are mistaken.

Source (Stackoverflow)

Comments