devnull - 9 months ago 55
Java Question

# Handling InterruptedException in Java

What is the difference between the following ways of handling

InterruptedException
? What is the best way to do it?

try{
//...
} catch(InterruptedException e) {
}


OR

try{
//...
} catch(InterruptedException e) {
throw new RuntimeException(e);
}


EDIT: I'd like to also know in which scenarios are these two used.

You've probably come to ask this question because you've called a method that throws InterruptedException.

First of all, you should see throws InterruptedException for what it is: A part of the method signature and a possible outcome of calling the method you're calling. So start by embracing the fact that an InterruptedException is a perfectly valid result of the method call.

Now, if the method you're calling throws such exception, what should your method do? You can figure out the answer by thinking about the following:

Does it make sense for the method you are implementing to throw an InterruptedException? Put differently, is an InterruptedException a sensible outcome when calling your method?

• If yes, then throws InterruptedException should be part of your method signature, and you should let the exception propagate (i.e. don't catch it at all).

Example: Your method waits for a value from the network to finish the computation and return a result. If the blocking network call throws an InterruptedException your method can not finish computation in a normal way. You let the InterruptedException propagate.

int computeSum(Server server) throws InterruptedException {
// Any InterruptedException thrown below is propagated
int a = server.getValueA();
int b = server.getValueB();
return a + b;
}

• If no, then you should not declare your method with throws InterruptedException and you should (must!) catch the exception. Now two things are important to keep in mind in this situation:

1. Someone interrupted your thread. That someone is probably eager to cancel the operation, terminate the program gracefully, or whatever. You should be polite to that someone and return from your method without further ado.

2. Even though your method can manage to produce a sensible return value in case of an InterruptedException the fact that the thread has been interrupted may still be of importance. In particular, the code that calls your method may be interested in whether an interruption occurred during execution of your method. You should therefor log the fact an interruption took place by setting the interrupted flag: Thread.currentThread().interrupt()

Example: The user has asked to print a the sum of two values. Printing "Failed to compute sum" is acceptable if the sum can't be computed (and much better than letting the program crash with a stack trace due to an InterruptedException). In other words, it does not make sense to declare this method with throws InterruptedException.

void printSum(Server server) {
try {
int sum = computeSum(server);
System.out.println("Sum: " + sum);
} catch (InterruptedException e) {
System.out.println("Failed to compute sum");
}
}


By now it should be clear that just doing throw new RuntimeException(e) is a bad idea. It isn't very polite to the caller. You could invent a new runtime exception but the root cause (someone wants the thread to stop execution) might get lost.

Other examples:

Implementing Runnable: As you may have discovered, the signature of Runnable.run does not allow for rethrowing InterruptedExceptions. Well, you signed up on implementing Runnable, which means that you signed up to deal with possible InterruptedExceptions. Either choose a different interface, such as Callable, or follow the second approach above.

Calling Thread.sleep: You're attempting read a file and the spec says you should try 10 times with 1 second in between. You call Thread.sleep(1000). So, you need to deal with InterruptedException. For a method such as tryToReadFile it makes perfect sense to say, "If I'm interrupted, I can't complete my action of trying to read the file". In other words, it makes perfect sense for the method to throw InterruptedExceptions.

String tryToReadFile(File f) throws InterruptedException {
for (int i = 0; i < 10; i++) {
if (f.exists())