7alman 7alman - 4 months ago 31
Bash Question

How do I pipe output from one python script as input to another python script?

For example:

A script1.py gets an infix expression from the user and converts it to a postfix expression and returns it or prints it to stdout

script2.py gets a postfix expression from stdin and evaluates it and outputs the value

I wanted to do something like this:

python3 script1.py | python3 script2.py

This doesn't work though, could you point me in the right direction as to how I could do this?


here are some more details as to what "doesn't work".

When I execute python3 script1.py | python3 script2.py
the terminal asks me for input for the script2.py program, when it should be asking for input for the script1.py program and redirecting that as script2.py's input.

So it asks me to "Enter a postfix expression: ", when it should be asking "Enter an infix expression: " and redirect that to the postfix script.


If I undestand your issue correctly, your two scripts each write out a prompt for input. For instance, they could both be something like this:

in_string = input("Enter something")

Where some_function is a function that has different output depending on the input string (which may be different in each script).

The issue is that the "Enter something" prompt doesn't get displayed to the user correctly when the output of one script is being piped to another script. That's because the prompt is written to standard output, so the first script's prompt is piped to the second script, while the second script's prompt is displayed. That's misleading, since it's the first script that will (directly) receive input from the user. The prompt text may also mess up the data being passed between the two scripts.

There's no perfect solution to this issue. One partial solution is to write the prompt to standard error, rather than standard output. This would let you see both prompts (though you'd only actually be able to respond to one of them). I don't think you can directly do that with input, but print can write to other file streams if you want: print("prompt", file=sys.stderr)

Another partial solution is to check if your input and output streams and skip printing the prompts if either one is not a "tty" (terminal). In Python, you can do sys.stdin.isatty(). Many command line programs have a different "interactive mode" if they're connected directly to the user, rather than to a pipe or a file.

If piping the output around is a main feature of your program, you may not want to use prompts ever! Many standard Unix command-line programs (like cat and grep) don't have any interactive behavior at all. They require the user to pass command line arguments or set environment variables to control how they run. That lets them work as expected even when they don't have access to standard input and standard output.